Should Ph.D. Holders Be Addressed as 'Doctor'?

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

In the debate over whether Ph.D. holders should be referred to as "doctor," it's essential to understand the historical and contemporary use of the title. Contrary to the belief that only medical doctors merit this designation, the term "doctor" originates from the Latin verb 'docere', meaning "to teach." This title applies aptly to individuals who have achieved a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) degree, recognizing their expertise and contributions to their fields of study.

mediaimage

The Historical Context of the Title 'Doctor'

Origins and Evolution

The title "doctor" was historically used to denote someone who was an established teacher or a learned individual in a specific area of study. This usage predates the modern association of the term exclusively with medical professionals. According to the Oxford English Dictionary,Should Ph.D. Holders Be Addressed as 'Doctor'? Articles the term has been used since the 1300s to refer to religious scholars and secular professionals alike.

Contemporary Usage

In modern contexts, the title is used in various professions, not just medicine. Prominent figures such as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., who held a Ph.D. in Systematic Theology, and Dr. Joyce Brothers, a psychologist, have been recognized publicly with this title despite their non-medical backgrounds.

Public Perception and Misconceptions

Survey Insights

A survey by Pew Research Center indicates that public respect for Ph.D. holders is significant, with 57% of Americans believing that they contribute "a lot" to society's well-being, which is just slightly lower than the 74% for medical doctors.

Addressing Common Arguments

Some argue that referring to Ph.D. holders as 'doctor' might confuse the public in situations requiring medical assistance. However, this underestimates public intelligence and awareness. Educational efforts can clarify the distinction between a Ph.D. and a medical doctor (MD).

Academic Rigor and Commitment

Comparison of Degree Challenges

Obtaining a Ph.D. involves extensive research, comprehensive exams, and a significant original contribution to one's field, often requiring 6-8 years post-bachelor's degree. In contrast, medical degrees in the U.S. typically require four years post-bachelor's, not including residency programs.

Data on Degree Difficulty

According to the National Science Foundation, only about 57% of Ph.D. students complete their degree within ten years, highlighting the rigorous nature and commitment required in Ph.D. programs.

Conclusion: Recognizing Expertise Across Fields

It is clear from both historical usage and contemporary practice that the title 'doctor' is appropriate for Ph.D. holders. Society benefits from recognizing the expertise and contributions of all individuals who achieve such high levels of academic and professional excellence, regardless of their field.

In conclusion, the title 'doctor' is not just a prefix but a recognition of significant academic achievement and expertise. As such, Ph.D. holders are as deserving of this title as their counterparts in the medical field. This acknowledgment not only respects their dedication but also enriches public understanding of what it means to be a doctor in various realms of expertise.