Liner ponds and pondless waterfalls are often marketed as attractive, low-maintenance water features for gardens and landscapes. However, the reality of their cost, durability, and safety can be quite different. A homeowner's experience of paying over $250,000 for a liner pond, only to spend an additional $75,000 on unsuccessful repairs, highlights the potential for these features to become expensive liabilities rather than valuable assets.
The concept of the pondless waterfall originated in Fallbrook, California, during the early 1980s, predating the use of rubber or PVC pond liners. Initially termed a "childproof waterfall," this design aimed to mitigate the risk of drowning for small children, a significant concern with traditional ponds and pools. The client's request for a waterfall without a pond was driven by space constraints, topographical challenges, and stringent building codes that imposed safety measures such as fencing and alarms for water bodies deeper than 18 inches.
The pondless waterfall addressed these issues by capturing water in a hidden cistern, thus eliminating the need for a visible pond. This design not only reduced maintenance by preventing debris accumulation and algae growth but also provided the soothing sounds and sights of a waterfall without the associated risks and upkeep.
The original childproof waterfall was constructed with 3500 psi concrete, stealth fiber, and #3 rebar spaced 8 inches apart, ensuring longevity and earthquake resistance. Properly sealed with concrete sealers like Thoroseal, these structures prevent harmful substances from leaching into the water, safeguarding aquatic life.
In contrast, modern pondless waterfalls often use rubber or PVC liners, which are promoted for their quick installation and cost-effectiveness. However, these materials may not provide the same durability or strength as concrete. For instance, a client in Rancho Santa Fe, California, faced a leaking waterfall and pond shortly after paying $276,000 for its construction with a liner. Rodents had damaged the liner, and subsequent repair attempts by another company, costing $75,000, failed to resolve the issue.
Ultimately, the solution involved removing the liner and replacing it with reinforced Shotcrete, enhancing the waterfall's size and efficiency at a lower cost than the original liner installation. This case illustrates that liner ponds and waterfalls can incur higher long-term costs due to repairs and replacements.
When evaluating the value of liner ponds and pondless waterfalls, it's crucial to consider the potential for hidden costs and liabilities. Loose rocks and boulders on liner waterfalls can shift or topple, posing safety hazards. In contrast, waterfalls constructed with mortar-secured rocks offer greater stability and reduced liability.
Advocates of liner ponds and waterfalls often highlight three main advantages:
However, these claims may not hold up under scrutiny. The profit margins for liner installations are high due to the speed of construction, but the likelihood of returning to address problems is a concern for homeowners.
Before investing in a liner pond or pondless waterfall, it's essential to weigh the long-term costs and benefits. While they may appear to be an attractive addition to your property, the potential for high repair costs, maintenance challenges, and safety risks could turn them into a financial burden.
For more information on pondless waterfalls and their construction, visit Design a Pond.
In conclusion, liner ponds and pondless waterfalls require careful consideration. They can be either a delightful feature or a costly mistake, depending on their construction and maintenance. Homeowners should thoroughly research and consider all factors before making such an investment.
Be Concerned, Be Very Concerned
Water serves three major purposes in our bodies. 1. It controls body temperature. 2. It is the solvent for the foods we eat, carrying the nutrients to every cell of our body. 3. Water replaces bodily fluids such as blood plasma, lymph, digestive juices, bile etc. and washes and bathes every cell, flushing and carrying away waste materials and toxic poisons. If water is so vital to our health and existence, shouldn't we drink the healthiest water possible?
Provident Living - Escape the Global Warming Madness
How will you cook if you no longer have electricity? Do you have a camp stove and an adequate supply of fuel? Using a solar oven eliminates the need to store fuel and will serve you well whether in an emergency situation or not.
The Durability of Concrete Ponds in Frigid Environments
Concrete ponds have often been criticized by proponents of pond liners, who claim that concrete is prone to cracking and cannot withstand the harsh conditions of cold climates. However, this article aims to dispel these myths by presenting the facts about the resilience of concrete ponds, especially when compared to rubber liners, and the engineering principles that ensure their longevity.
