According to a new report issued by The Project on Student
Debt, one-third of all college students who graduated in 2009 were carrying
private student loans, and private student loans accounted for nearly
one-fourth of all student loan volume in 2007-08. College students who graduated
with private student loans owed about $12,500 in private loan debt.
Private student loans
are credit-based, non-federal college loans issued by banks and private
lenders. Unlike with government-issued college loans, the federal government
does not guarantee private student loans and does not regulate the industry
outside of standard lending laws.
Whereas federal student loans carry fixed interest rates,
private student loans are typically variable-rate loans, with generally higher
interest rates and without the flexible repayment options and borrower
protections offered by federal loans.
The Project on Student Debt compares private student loans
to credit cards insofar as the high, variable interest rates and the associated
risks to borrowers.
Financial Aid Counseling Linked to Less Debt From
Private Student Loans
In compiling student loan debt data for its report, The
Project on Student Debt found that
students who received additional financial aid counseling from their school
about the availability of federal financial aid — which includes
federal grants and low-cost federal student loans — tended to take out
fewer private student loans than those students who did not receive such
counseling.
This finding, say the researchers, suggests the need for more
financial aid counseling at the school level. Students can benefit from
financial guidance regarding college loans and college loan debt, and researchers
at The Project on Student Debt recommend that financial aid counseling
specifically address the differences between federal student aid and private
student loans.
Recommendations for Greater Transparency of
Student Loan Debt Levels
The report, “Student
Debt and the Class of 2009,” is the latest issue in the annual survey
published each fall by The Project on Student Debt, an initiative sponsored by the
Institute for College Access & Success (ICAS), an independent nonprofit
organization dedicated to making higher education more affordable and available
to students of all backgrounds.
In addition to its proposal for expanded financial aid
counseling for students, this year’s report makes additional recommendations
aimed at providing students and schools with more complete and better
accessible student loan data and information about student loan debt loads:
Institute the uniform collection of total
student loan debt loads for all undergraduate students, not just
first-year enrollees. A current annual federal financial aid survey of colleges
collects student loan debt information only from entering first-year students
and only for government-issued college loans; student debt from private student
loans isn’t included.
Cumulative data on total student loan debt loads for
graduating students, which should include annual borrowing volume for both federal
and private student loans, says ICAS, are needed to create
a truer picture of the cost of college and the extent to which students are
taking on student loan debt to pay for college.
Require private student loans to be
“certified” by the school. Such a certification would require colleges
and universities to verify a student’s enrollment status and financial aid
eligibility before a lender could disburse any private student loan dollars. The
certification process would allow each school to counsel students on their
remaining eligibility for federal student loans and other potential
alternatives to private student loans.
Both private lenders and the National Association of Student
Financial Aid Administrators support this type of certification, and most
currently available private student loan programs offer only school-certified
private student loans.
Require that private student loans
be entered into the National Student Loan Data System. The National Student Loan Data System
(NSLDS), which offers students online access to their full profile of federal
grants and student loan borrowing history, currently contains information only
on government-issued student loans. No similar centralized database for private
student loans exists. ICAS notes that the new Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, created under the Obama administration’s financial reform legislation,
has the rulemaking authority to require the entry of private loans into the
NSLDS.
Instituting such a policy, says ICAS, will enable the
consolidation of all student loan debt data for a single borrower. Student
borrowers would be able to see, within a single location, their total current
college loan debt load from both federal and private student loans and would be
able to use that information to inform any further borrowing decisions.
In addition, the inclusion of private loans within the NSLDS
would allow colleges and universities to assess the rate at which their
students are using private student loans to pay for tuition and living expenses
while in college. Knowing the uptake rate of private student loans may help
colleges and universities make more scholarships and grant aid available to
students or encourage schools to reduce the overall cost of attendance.
Make every school’s student loan
repayment rates and graduate debt-to-income ratios publicly available.
Currently, a proposed federal regulation would require this data only from
for-profit colleges and other programs that incur high student loan debt rates
and also have low post-graduation student loan repayment rates.
Collecting and publishing student loan repayment rates,
student loan debt loads, and graduate debt-to-income information for all
programs that prepare students for gainful employment, not merely a select troubled
few, says ICAS, would provide a more accurate picture of program costs among higher
education institutions as well as of the likelihood of finding gainful
employment following graduation.
Include student loan debt loads and
borrowing trends from students who start but do not finish their degree
program. Students who drop out of college before attaining their
degree are at a significantly higher risk of defaulting on their student loans.
The inclusion in federal financial aid surveys and databases of student loan
debt information from all student borrowers, regardless of degree attainment,
says ICAS, will provide a truer picture of student loan debt loads and default risks associated with particular
schools and programs and may allow students to make more informed choices when
they select a degree program.
Jeff Mictabor is an enthusiast on the topic of student loan
issues in the news. He has been writing for the past 10 years for a variety of
education publications. He now offers his writing services on a freelance
basis.