Does yoga really work?

Jun 24
07:13

2015

Prakash Chand

Prakash Chand

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

With the hype generated over the International Yoga day, I am sure many of us have been tempted to try out some Asanas. So after my usual Sunday long run I decided to do one or 2 Asanas. We look at 5 asanas and see if their method makes any medical logic.

mediaimage

Monday morning and a freshly brewed coffee got me thinking does Yoga really work? A quick search over the Internet showed Yoga cures at least 10 diseases. This seems very interesting and I decided to delve deeper and uncover how contorting your body can cure disease.

Here are 5 Asanas I attempt to demistify:

  1. Pranayama - Asthma
  2. Triangle pose Asana - Diabetes
  3. Child pose Asana - Indigestion
  4. Sirasana - Migraine headaches
  5. Uttanasana - Depression

At first look,Does yoga really work? Articles I am ambivalent on the efficacy of yoga on these illnesses. Looking from a medical point of view, all the diseases above can be considered life style diseases. And modifying your life style with some changes can help you treat them. Yoga does recommend life style changes but the question is if the asanas alone help. All asanas do promote and change blood flow but I want to go in-depth and review all the asanas and see exactly what happens when an Asana is done.

1.Pranayama

Pranayama is the art and science of yogic breathing techniques. Practitioners of Yoga claim that it helps fight off diseases such as weight gain and also asthma. Asthma is basically an increased hypersensitivity or responsiveness of the wind pipe to any allergen. So we need to see if Pranayama can help reduce this sensitivity. Pranayama claims to improve the amount of air getting to all parts of the lung. Theoretically, even though your lungs can expand to more maximum than they are in normal breathing, the amount of extra oxygen coming in would be minimal.

The second logic given is that the increased respiration causes movement of lymph that boosts the immune system. This logic does has some merit.

But, Prayanama is not completely safe. Exhaling is done against a closed glottis and this can increase lung pressure leading to hematomas or pneumothorax.

I would say a medical exam would be necessary to see if you can perform the exercise. Alternatively, you can consult a Doctor online to help clear you for this Asana.

2.Triangle pose Asana

Also known as the Trikona-asana. This is an asana where the legs are spread to the shape of a triangle and person bends sideways in such a way to face the sky. And the opposite hand is pointed to the sky. Trikona-asana claims to cure type 2 diabetes. The treatment of type 2 Diabetes is by diet and exercise(1st line treatment). Assuming you do yoga but keep consuming lots of sugary foods, it is unlikely to help. However, supposing you restricted your diet, you can lose some weight with repetition of this asana as it is relatively an aerobic activity. So, you do burn calories naturally by this method and help fight diabetes. But, I would not recommend that you stop medication and hope that yoga alone will help.

3.Child pose Asana

Also known as the Shishuasana. This asana claims to help with indigestion. The logic is that the intestine is put under pressure and also the sphincters of the gastrointestinal tract are relaxed. And their is then smooth passage of stools. This seems logical as the increased pressure with the relaxed sphincters will logically help with bowel movement. But, I would recommend you take a Doctor’s advice if the Indigestion/Constipation do not stop. Also, you can talk to our Doctors online to get a good diet plan to stop indigestion and constipation.

4.Sirasana

This is a supported headstand and is also nicknamed the king of all asanas. This asana claims to increase the blood flow to the brain which is not exactly correct as the body regulates the blood pressure and will not allow a big change in the blood to the brain. Also, assuming that it does in fact increase blood flow to the head, it actually increases the chance of a person getting a migraine.

A migraine or headache occurs due to dilatation of the blood vessels in the head. So increasing blood flow to the head would actually make things worse. I also think doing this asana while having a headache will make things worse.

If you are not recovering from your headache, I would recommend you ask our Doctors for a few things you can try at askthedoctor.com

5.Uttanasana

This is a very physical type of stretch and I do not understand how this would help with depression. One logic may be that this allows stretching of certain muscles and increasing the pain which in turn releases epinephrine which can fight off depression. The effects are not going to be astronomical however and I would recommend people to exercise caution if they are diagnosed and not to stop medications if they are on any.