Pessimistic. Negative. Or Just a Critical Thinker?

Apr 21
08:05

2011

Karen Keller, Ph.D.

Karen Keller, Ph.D.

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

Despite what people tell you, seeing the glass as half empty is not how you prepare yourself for potential challenges or barriers that block your progress. The ‘half-empty’ perspective asks you to entertain negative thoughts, a pessimistic attitude and an angry frightened view of the world.

mediaimage

A group of anthropologists at Cambridge were conducting research on the concepts of pessimism and optimism. Their subjects were two young boys: one a pessimist and the other an optimist. The pessimistic boy was put in a room full of wonderful toys. The optimistic boy was put in a room with nothing but a barrel of manure.

When the scientist looked in on the pessimistic boy one hour later they found him complaining about this toy that didn't work,Pessimistic. Negative. Or Just a Critical Thinker?  Articles that one needed fresh batteries, the next one wasn't the rights color, etc., etc. Recording their findings, they moved on.

As they opened the door to the room where the optimistic boy was, they had to duck to avoid being hit by flying manure. Indeed, manure was splattered everywhere. They found the young lad head-first in the barrel, where he was heard to say, "I know there's a pony in here somewhere."

Despite what people tell you, seeing the glass as half empty is not how you prepare yourself for potential challenges or barriers that block your progress. The ‘half-empty’ perspective asks you to entertain negative thoughts, a pessimistic attitude and an angry frightened view of the world. 

If you are prone to the ‘half-empty’ perspective, there is a way to move away from that mindset and into a mindset of ‘half-full’ optimistic thinking. Being in a state of mind that is optimistic doesn’t imply you are a ‘Pollyanna’, not in touch with reality, or wearing blinders. Being optimistic won’t get in the way of effectively defending or preparing yourself. 

Practice critical thinking. Look at all the scenarios; good, bad or ugly. Being a critical thinker while seeing the glass as ‘half-full’ lets you see situations, problems or opportunities in a balanced way. You keep your fears and reactionary emotions in check. 

Research shows that people with an optimistic life-view tend to outperform pessimists in all respects. This represents the steady impact of our thoughts, expectations and beliefs on our behavior. The way your reason or offer critical thought with yourself about the things that happen to you has a huge impact on your success – everywhere; home, work, school and community. 

Being optimistic or pessimistic is a learned behavior – you aren’t born with it. It’s learned through experience or through other people telling us how to be. Since this behavior is learned it can be unlearned. How? 

For every setback you encounter, you need to interpret them as challenges or mountains to be climbed and conquered. Your attitude plays a critical role in supporting a ‘this will not break me’ mindset. Setbacks are seen as temporary and good events are permanent. 

Which do you entertain on a daily basis? It could be an indication of what lies ahead.