Reassessing the Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Employment and Economic Growth

Feb 14


Sam Vaknin

Sam Vaknin

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

In a world where globalization and international trade are pivotal to economic development, the role of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has been a subject of extensive debate. Nikola Gruevski, the former Prime Minister of North Macedonia, delves into this topic in his book "The Way Out: Foreign Direct Investment, Economic Development, and Employment," published in October 2007 by Evropa 92 Kochani. The 210-page book, which is based on Gruevski's Master's Thesis, offers a comprehensive analysis of FDI's influence on emerging and developing economies, with a particular focus on employment.

A Closer Look at FDI and Economic Development

Gruevski's work is commendable for its thorough examination of FDI in the context of economic development. His insights are particularly relevant for countries transitioning from socialist regimes to capitalist economies,Reassessing the Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Employment and Economic Growth Articles such as North Macedonia. However, the book's reliance on the same strategies proposed a decade earlier raises questions about its applicability in a rapidly evolving global economy.

The Limitations of FDI in Smaller Economies

The comparison of Macedonia to countries like Ireland or Singapore is problematic due to the vast differences in market size, language proficiency, and geographical advantages. Gruevski's vision for Macedonia's economic revival through FDI seems to overlook these critical disparities.

The Contested Role of FDI in Growth and Development

Despite the common perception of FDI as a catalyst for economic growth, its effectiveness remains unproven. According to the World Bank, FDI only accounts for a small fraction of global GDP, and its impact on local economies is often overshadowed by other financial flows such as remittances and Official Development Assistance (ODA).

The Complex Relationship Between FDI and Local Investment

FDI does not always result in net foreign exchange inflows. Multinational companies frequently finance their investments through local borrowing, which can lead to unfair competition and crowd out domestic firms. This displacement of local investment is a significant concern for developing economies.

The Questionable Benefits of FDI on Employment

Contrary to popular belief, FDI does not necessarily create a substantial number of jobs. Foreign-owned projects tend to be capital-intensive, favoring machinery and technology over human labor. Moreover, mergers and acquisitions, which make up a significant portion of FDI, often result in job losses rather than gains.

The Misuse of FDI Funds in Developing Countries

In countries with corrupt governance, FDI can exacerbate economic disparities. Instead of contributing to sustainable development, FDI funds may end up in private pockets, fueling asset bubbles and unsustainable consumption patterns.

The True Nature of FDI: A Catalyst or a Follower?

While FDI can facilitate the transfer of skills and technology, it is not the primary driver of economic growth. Instead, FDI tends to follow growth, attracted to countries that are already on an upward trajectory in terms of political stability and market potential.

Conclusion: Rethinking the Role of FDI

Gruevski's "The Way Out" provides a valuable perspective on the role of FDI in economic development. However, policymakers and economists must critically assess the actual impact of FDI on employment and growth, considering the unique circumstances of each country. The nuanced relationship between FDI and local economies suggests that a one-size-fits-all approach is insufficient for addressing the challenges faced by developing nations.


The bibliography provided in Gruevski's book includes a range of studies on FDI, offering insights into its effects on domestic investment, employment, and economic growth. These works contribute to a broader understanding of the complex dynamics at play when foreign investment enters a developing economy.

For further reading on the impact of FDI on economic development, readers may refer to the World Bank's research on the topic, as well as studies published by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).