In the niche world of water gardening, a storm brews beneath the serene surface. As enthusiasts and professionals engage in heated debates on online forums, the industry's integrity is called into question. This article delves into the contentious issue of pond liner usage, contrasting the loyalty and camaraderie expected within the community with the stark reality of business practices that prioritize profit over quality.
Water garden forums, often a haven for sharing knowledge and experiences, have become battlegrounds for ideological clashes. The expectation of mutual support and pride within the community has been overshadowed by divisive tactics and profit-driven agendas.
In the early 1990s, Greg Witstock, dubbed the "Liner Messiah," ignited the pond liner movement with his company, Aquascape Design Inc. This initiative led to a nationwide network of installers, referred to as "disciples," who adopted Witstock's marketing strategies and product line. Aquascape's comprehensive training materials and sales tools promised success for those who followed their prescribed methods.
Despite the glossy exterior, the pond liner industry faces criticism for peddling overpriced and subpar products. According to Bob Wilder, author of "48-Hour Waterfall" and a pond liner installer for 18 years, the industry's own statistics paint a grim picture:
These figures are corroborated by my own experience in the field. Over 26 years, I have constructed more than 1,900 concrete and rebar waterfalls and ponds, often replacing faulty liner ponds with more durable materials and offering lifetime warranties.
The pond liner craze, driven by the potential for quick profits, has even attracted professionals with advanced degrees to abandon their careers for liner installation. However, as awareness of the liners' unreliability grows, the industry's reputation for business ethics and craftsmanship is at stake. Customers deceived by incomplete information about the drawbacks of liners are increasingly vocal in their discontent.
On water garden forums, discussions often turn to the high cost of Aquascape products and the possibility of finding cheaper alternatives with longer warranties. Despite using Aquascape's marketing materials, installers are accused of disloyalty for sourcing less expensive products elsewhere.
When I attempted to share insights on concrete pond construction and high-quality pumps on one such forum, I was met with resistance and ultimately banned. It became clear that the forum administrator had vested interests in the liner industry.
In the face of adversity, I advocate for integrity and character. I encourage water garden enthusiasts to construct their ponds with robust materials like 4500psi concrete and rebar, ensuring longevity and satisfaction for years to come.
As the industry evolves, it's crucial for consumers to be well-informed and for professionals to uphold ethical standards. The water garden community must navigate these turbulent waters with care, ensuring that the beauty and tranquility of their creations are not undermined by questionable practices.
For a deeper understanding of the debate surrounding pond liners, consider reading "Pond Liners: Seven Reasons Why I Don’t Use Them" by Doug Hoover. As the conversation continues, it's clear that the water garden industry is at a crossroads, with its reputation and the satisfaction of its customers hanging in the balance.
Be Concerned, Be Very Concerned
Water serves three major purposes in our bodies. 1. It controls body temperature. 2. It is the solvent for the foods we eat, carrying the nutrients to every cell of our body. 3. Water replaces bodily fluids such as blood plasma, lymph, digestive juices, bile etc. and washes and bathes every cell, flushing and carrying away waste materials and toxic poisons. If water is so vital to our health and existence, shouldn't we drink the healthiest water possible?
Provident Living - Escape the Global Warming Madness
How will you cook if you no longer have electricity? Do you have a camp stove and an adequate supply of fuel? Using a solar oven eliminates the need to store fuel and will serve you well whether in an emergency situation or not.
The Durability of Concrete Ponds in Frigid Environments
Concrete ponds have often been criticized by proponents of pond liners, who claim that concrete is prone to cracking and cannot withstand the harsh conditions of cold climates. However, this article aims to dispel these myths by presenting the facts about the resilience of concrete ponds, especially when compared to rubber liners, and the engineering principles that ensure their longevity.
